Well, the title of this post is pretty open ended. Let me be more specific…I’m talking about Brett Favre and Aaron Rodgers. I’ll let you figure out which one gets which title. First, let me state that I’m a 49ers fan and I have the greatest respect for Brett Favre. I actually LIKE Brett Favre as a football player. How can you not marvel at his athletic ability? He’s set records all over the field for his quarterback skills and durability. Unfortunately for Favre, his records won’t stand for very long; thanks to a guy named Peyton Manning.
From the perspective of a normal football fan, I’d say Favre was seen in a favorable light for most of his career. That is, until he retired and un-retired numerous times, with what seems like blatant disregard for the teams involved. Now, I’m not saying the decision to walk away is easy. We know that is not the case. However, can you really be that unsure? Maybe the first time, but not the second or third time. I’m sure it’s hard to keep your massive ego in check when you’ve been the man for how many years, but still, it’s a little ridiculous.
Now, the guy who had to endure during the first Favre retirement fiasco: Aaron Rodgers. I wasn’t really fond of Rodgers in college. Mostly, because he played for Cal and I’m not a big fan of ANY Pac-10 team. I tend to think those teams are soft and typically play an easier schedule than the rest of the nation when it comes to football.
I did feel bad for Rodgers on draft day when he slipped all the way to number 24 in the first round. He was anticipated to go much higher. In fact, he was one of the guys picked to sit at the “VIP” table, or whatever they call the table where all the big shot draft picks sit for the ESPN coverage of draft day. He was the last one at that table for a very long time until Green Bay picked him at 24.
Rodgers handled the Favre retirement ordeal about as good as one could be expected to handle such an awkward situation. Rodgers’ has also had his playing ability and overall NFL quarterback cred called into question. How has he responded? Not with bickering, complaining, or media outlet arguments. Nope, he’s done his talking on the field, and has managed to position the Packers as an NFC favorite with an unbelievable offensive arsenal at his disposal. Now, many folks are singing his praises.
You can take anything you wish from this story. Obviously, Favre has had many ups and downs in his career and I’m not one to believe his reputation will be damaged over these retirement situations. I don’t actively root for Favre near as much these days, but I don’t wish him any ill will. I’d honestly just like to see him ride off into the sunset. Then, we have Rodgers, who’s career has just started and looks promising. As of right now, he’s exhibited great character and ability on the field. Now, I actually root for Rodgers, and I truly hope he keeps his composure for the length of his NFL career. Obviously, a feat that isn’t as easy as it appears…